CROSSCHECKING THE PCB ASSEMBLY COMPONENT FOOTPRINT & BOM FOOTPRINT


Periodically there maybe a need to verify via inspection that the footprint on the bare PC board assembly for a component matches the footprint (correct solder pad size and land pattern) for the same component listed in the Bill of Materials (BOM).  

The mismatch of component footprint spacing is usually an error created when components on the PCB are part sourced and then those part sourced components are reflected in the BOM that is then used to assemble the PCB.   The problem occurs when the components that are part sourced are incorrectly chosen and do not match the footprint spacing initially specified when the PCB was originally designed on the CAD system and then end up in the final BOM and so these components do not fit the landing pad area on the bare PC board.    

There are several methods using the Unisoft software for
crosschecking the component footprint in the CAD file or bareboard gerbers with the shapes listed via the part numbers in the BOM and below are listed some of those options.  The procedures listed below assume some working knowledge of the Unisoft software. Please contact Unisoft directly for details.



Note that for all shape crosschecking methods listed below on this webpage visual details of many types can be added to the display as desired.  For example as in the figure below a photograph of the bare or loaded PCB board can be added to the display and the part shape information, manufacturers part number and other information from the Bill of Material (BOM) can be overlaid on the components and this can be compared the the component pins display from the CAD file imported into the Unisoft software. At that point mismatch of component footprints can be detected.

Further Gerber silkscreen information, etc. can be overlayed on the display. Additionally each part number and its components can be blinked on the display and also checked off and colored for inspection verification.  

Also user hyperlinks to any component information (footprint, electrical, ECO, etc.) can be added for each part number or use the direct links supplied in the Unisoft software to the manufacturer part number information available from popular part source vendor such as Digikey, Ultra Librarian, Sourcengine, Octopart, FindChips, etc.

component-cross-check-1



Method 1:

In this method we will be checking for:

                                        - The span of components on the PCB against the BOM using the Smart Color window on the display. 

                                        - A crosscheck done by comparing the device pin count on the pcb board layout to the BOM using the Smart Color window on the display.  .



SPAN CROSSCHECK:


The Unisoft software imports the CAD or Gerber files and then calculates the maximum span of all components on the PC board. This span measurement is the furthest distance of the centers of any 2 pins on the device.   So for example for a 2 pin device 0603 package the span distance would be measured and listed as approximately 60 mils. This can then be compared to what is listed for the same device and the BOM when it is imported into the Unisoft software and if there is a discrepancy it can be addressed.

For example using the Unisoft Smart Color window on the display quality inspection of the components can be validated from the foot print of the component on the board to what is listed in the BOM. 

The Smart Color window in the Unisoft software is displayed in the figure below and in one of the columns is the Shape footprint indicated in the BOM and the other column is the Span (Mils) and this field is the actual measured distance of the component on the PC board. These 2 columns should correlate and if they do not then there is a discrepancy that should be investigated. 

footprint-part-shape-inspection-2


Note that above the span measurement is from the centers of the 2 extreme pins on the device. So for example a 0603 device listed in the BOM would be thought to be 60 mils but the actual measurement calculated maybe slightly more or less and still be correct.  For example in the figure above it is 62 mils for one of the 0603 shape component part numbers.  And 74 mils for the two 0805 shape component part numbers (0805 would be approximately 80 mils).  Then for the 1210 shape component part number the span measured is 120 mils (a 1210 shape would be approximately 120 mils).

 


PIN COUNT CROSSCHECK:


Also a crosscheck can be done by comparing the device pin count on the pcb board layout to the BOM and this is done by using the Pins field located in the Smart Color window. In the
figure below we see that the Pins field gives the total number of pins for each part number and this field can be used to verify against the BOM.  For example if the Pins field which represents the PCB layout indicates that there are 16 pins for that device part number and in the BOM it indicates that there are 14 pins then an error has been detected.  In the figure below both the Description and the Shape fields where imported from the BOM and either field may indicate a discrepancy in the board footprint to BOM footprint crosscheck.  

The first part number in the figure below indicates that it is both 14 pins in the Pins field and also in the Description field it is 14 pins and further in the Shape field it is an SOIC-14 which is 14 pins and so this part number does not have a pins count discrepancy. However in the second part number below we see that the Pins field indicates that it's 16 pins on the PCB assembly however both the Description field and the Shape field from the BOM indicates that it's 14 pins so we know there's a discrepancy in our board footprint to BOM footprint crosscheck.


footprint-part-shape-inspection-3




Method 2:

In this method we will be checking for the span of components on the PCB against the BOM using a file created. 

The Unisoft software imports the CAD or Gerber files and then calculates the maximum span of all components on the PC board. This span measurement is the furthest distance of the centers of any 2 pins on the device.   So for example for a 2 pin device 0603 package the span distance would be measured and listed as approximately 60 mils. This can then be compared to what is listed for the same device and the BOM when it is imported into the Unisoft software and if there is a discrepancy it can be addressed.

For example using the Output Flat File feature of the software a file can be exported and then quality inspection of the components can be validated from the foot print of the component on the board to what is listed in the BOM. 

We have used the Output Flat File feature of the software to create the file in the figure below and in one of the columns is the Shape footprint indicated in the BOM and the other column is the Span (Mils) and is the actual measured distance of the component on the PC board. These 2 columns should correlate and if they do not then there is a discrepancy that should be investigated. 


footprint-part-shape-inspection

Note that the span measurement is from the centers of the 2 extreme pins on the device. So for example a 0603 device listed in the BOM would be thought to be 60 mils but the actual measurement calculated maybe slightly more or less. For example in the figure above it is 71 mils for one of the 0603 shape components and 59 mils for the other 0603 component.




Additional methods:


IMPORT THE CAD OR GERBER FILE AND BOM AND CHECK THE FOOTPRINT DIMENSIONS:

For aiding inspection in checking the component footprint on the PCB assembly / PCBA for the correct solder pad size and land pattern to the component listed in the Bill of Material (BOM) the Unisoft software allows you to import either the CAD or Gerber files or both. Then you can import the BOM data and that information is now displayed and associated with the components on the PCB.

crosscheck-pcb-component-footprint-and-bom-footprint-1


You can then blink by part number and those components will blink on the display. Even if there are multiple components for the part number usually only 1 component in each part number on the Unisoft display needs to be inspected to make sure the component spacing on the PCB assembly bare board fits what's listed in the BOM. 

For example if the part number in the BOM indicates a 1206 component shape then the footprint on the PCB bare board where the components for the selected part number are blinking should have that shape also (correct solder pad size and land pattern).  So in the figure below usually only 1 component, such as R14 or R15, needs to be inspected of the 16 component reference designators listed for that part number.

crosscheck-pcb-component-footprint-and-bom-footprint-2


You can also have dimension data displayed to aid the inspection.   Dimension data can be displayed in the OPERATION window and then the Measurement Tool can be used to measure the footprint for the component on the PCB and if they match then the crosscheck is good.  

For example in the picture below we are checking only one reference designator R10 for the part number 391727-10-9 .  We located R10 by blinking it on the display which from the OPERATION field indicates it is  3.22mm  and if that is what's measured then the crosscheck is ok and we can move onto the next part number.

sample-library_footprint-part-shape-inspection


The OPERATION field can be populated 3 ways. Either automatically from the BOM or manually from the Smart Color window or it can be populated from a library similar to the one below .

390222-06-2     0.25mm x 0.125mm, 0201
390222-07-1     0.4 mm × 0.2 mm, 0402
390579-03-3     2.0mm x 2.0mm, SOT23
391729-02-0     3.2mm x 2.5mm, 1210
391727-10-9     3.2mm x 1.6mm, 1206
391727-12-5     3.2mm x 1.6mm, 1206
391727-13-3     3.2mm x 1.6mm, 1206
391727-14-1     3.2mm x 1.6mm, 1206
391777-06-8     3.2mm x 1.6mm, 1206
391777-08-4     4.5 mm × 3.2 mm, 1812
395422-01-9     4.8mm x 3.8mm, SOIC8
391818-06-6     7.62mm x 5.75mm, SOIC14
391809-01-6     8.8mm x 8.8mm, PLCC20
391829-03-3     10.3mm x 2.25mm, SOIC20
391770-01-2     11.2mm x 5.6mm, SOM16
391770-02-0     11.2mm x 5.6mm, SOM16
395391-01-6     15.5mm x 15.5mm, PLCC20 Socket
391822-01-2     15.88mm x 7.49mm, SOIC48
391822-02-0     15.88mm x 7.49mm, SOIC48
391822-03-9     15.88mm x 7.49mm, SOIC48
390607-01-0     16.510mm x 16.510mm, PLCC44
390579-03-3     25.019mm x 25.019mm, PLCC68

 



Many manufacturers of semiconductor IC's and passive components use package outlines and dimensions according to JEDEC, IEC and JEITA
organization standards but there can be products also in non-standard package outlines.





OPTIONAL:  BRING IN A PHOTO OF THE BARE OR LOADED PCB. 

To add more realism to the display for solder pad size, land pattern, etc. you can also bring in a photo of the bare or loaded PC Board and place it to the back of the display to enhance the visual detail of the components being blinked and inspected.  

crosscheck-pcb-component-footprint-and-bom-footprint-2b


component-cross-check-1




OPTIONAL:  LOOKUP THE COMPONENT SHAPE, ETC, INFORMATION VIA DIGIKEY, OCTOPART, FINDCHIPS, ETC.
You can lookup the component shape information and more via Digikey, Octopart, Findchips, etc.  Components can be searched by vendor part number or electronic component number or name.

crosscheck-pcb-component-footprint-and-bom-footprint-3


The result is component information such as part footprint shape, electrical specifications, cost, availability, etc. is displayed.

crosscheck-pcb-component-footprint-and-bom-footprint-4


The component footprint dimensions (correct solder pad size and land pattern) can be found.

crosscheck-pcb-component-footprint-and-bom-footprint-5



Also the internal electronic functionality, etc. can be searched.

crosscheck-pcb-component-footprint-and-bom-footprint-6




OPTIONAL:  AUTOMATICALLY LOAD THE SHAPE INFORMATION VIA THE UNISOFT LIBRARY INTO THE OPERATION ASSOCIATED WITH THE PART NUMBER.

A simple library associating the component part number with any component information you wish via a link on the web or on your server can be created.  For example the link can point to component shape information for crosschecking the footprint in the cad file or bareboard gerbers with the shapes listed in the part numbers in the BOM.


crosscheck-pcb-component-footprint-and-bom-footprint-7


Those links can be imported automatically and match to the part number on the display.


crosscheck-pcb-component-footprint-and-bom-footprint-8


The browser can then be launched and the result is any type of component information you have at that link is displayed. For example detailed inspection information such as footprint shape pad size, electrical specifications, cost, availability, etc.

crosscheck-pcb-component-footprint-and-bom-footprint-9


For example the component footprint dimensions (correct solder pad size and land pattern).  

crosscheck-pcb-component-footprint-and-bom-footprint-5



MISC:  CHECKING GERBER DATA TO THE BARE BOARD VIA PHOTO.

On occasion there may be a need to check the bare board to the Gerber data for footprint lineup, etc. In this case we are not concerned about any BOM issues.

To do this bring the Gerber data into the Unisoft software then optionally Make the components.  Bring in a photograph of the bare PC Board using the annotation tool and send it to the back of the display. At this point the bare PC Board pads from the photo can be checked that they line up with the Gerber footprints displayed.



MISC:  CHECKING CAD DATA TO THE BARE BOARD GERBER DATA OR PHOTO OF THE BARE BOARD.

On occasion there may be a need to check the bare board to the CAD data for footprint lineup, etc. In this case we are not concerned about any BOM issues.

To do this bring the CAD data into the Unisoft software then either use the Ad Layer feature to add Gerber on top of the CAD data or bring in a photograph of the bare PC Board using the annotation tool and send it to the back of the display. At this point the bare PC Board pads from either the Gerber data or photo can be checked that they line up with the CAD data footprints displayed.


Contact our webmaster (enable JavaScript for the email address) with questions or comments about this web site.

Web Consulting by Dorene Matney
© 2024, Unisoft